🎧
⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ 4/5
A serial killer who's stopped counting his kills.
A woman who has no idea she's the reason he keeps going.
And a story that flat out tells you upfront it isn't going to end happily.
Under Your Scars audiobook is Ariel N. Anderson's dark romance about Elena Young and the two dangerous men orbiting her life, and it has built a genuinely intense following since it came out.
Quick note before anything else: this is a mature, explicit dark romance with heavy trigger content. Check the content warnings before diving in, seriously.
Listen to it if: you want an intense, unapologetically dark romance that doesn't pull punches.
Skip it if: you need a guaranteed happy ending or want to avoid heavy, disturbing themes.
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Title | Under Your Scars: A Dark Romance Novel |
| Author | Ariel N. Anderson |
| Narrator(s) (audiobook) | Lee Daniels, Joe Arden (dual narration) |
| Series | Under Your Scars, Book 1 |
| Genre | Romance |
| Subgenre | Dark romance, romantic suspense |
| Audiobook length | 19 hrs 2 mins (unabridged) |
| First published | 2023 (audiobook released July 2025) |
| Publisher | Blue Nose Publishing |
Content note: this book deals with heavy, disturbing themes and is intended for mature listeners only. It does not have a traditional happy ending. Please look up detailed trigger warnings before starting if you're sensitive to dark content.
Elena Young doesn't know it yet, but she's become the reason a serial killer keeps breathing.
He calls himself the Silencer. The FBI started counting his kills after the third one. By the time this story catches up to him, that number has climbed a lot higher, and somewhere along the way, Elena became the one thing keeping him from putting a bullet in himself. At the same time, Elena's life is tangled up with Christian Reeves, a powerful and controlling man who sees her less as a person to love and more as something to possess. Two dangerous men, both drawn to her for very different reasons, and Elena caught in the middle of it without fully understanding what either of them actually wants from her.
The book leans hard into obsession, power, and the blurry line between love and control. It's not a gentle read, and it doesn't pretend to be one. Anderson tells you straight out this isn't a story with a tidy happy-ever-after. That's rare in romance, and it's part of why this book generates such strong reactions.
Elena is the emotional center of the book, caught between two men who each want something different from her, and neither option is exactly safe. Christian represents control dressed up as devotion. His version of love comes with conditions, and the tension in his scenes comes from watching how far that control stretches before it breaks something.
The Silencer is the more complicated figure here. A man who's done genuinely terrible things, and yet the book asks you to understand him, maybe even root for him a little, which is exactly the kind of morally messy territory dark romance readers come looking for. Whether that works for you really depends on how you feel about morally gray, dangerous love interests in fiction. Some readers find it thrilling. Others find it a lot to sit with.
What keeps this triangle from feeling like a gimmick is that Anderson doesn't let any of these three characters off easy. Elena isn't a passive damsel, and neither man gets to be simply good or simply evil.
A lot of dark romance promises intensity and then softens at the last minute. This one genuinely doesn't. The choice to skip a traditional happy ending is a big swing, and it's clearly resonated, given how often it comes up in reader discussions. The dual narration in the audiobook version also sets it apart from a lot of self-published romance audio, giving the two male leads distinct voices instead of one narrator switching gears.
The honest criticism: this book asks a lot of its listeners. The explicit content is frequent and intense, to the point where even fans mention needing to skip through certain scenes. And the dark themes, self-harm, trauma, violence woven throughout, aren't background noise. They're central to the plot. If you're not specifically looking for that intensity, this probably isn't the right entry point into dark romance.
Lee Daniels and Joe Arden narrate in duet, splitting the perspectives between them, and this is consistently the most praised part of the whole production. Reader and listener reviews single out the narration again and again as exceptional. Having two distinct voices for two very different male leads makes a real difference in a story built around obsession and control. You're never confused about which man's headspace you're in.
Is the Under Your Scars audiobook worth it if you're new to dark romance in audio? Honestly, if the genre and content warnings work for you, yes. The performances add a layer of intensity that print alone doesn't quite deliver. At 19 hours, the Under Your Scars audiobook length is a real commitment, longer than most thrillers or romances you'd typically pick up, so pace yourself accordingly.
Good fit if you:
Maybe not for you if:
Q: Is Under Your Scars audiobook worth listening to?
A: If dark, explicit romance with heavy themes is what you're looking for, yes, this delivers on that promise fully. It's not a fit for readers who want lighter content or a conventional happy ending.
Q: How long is the Under Your Scars audiobook?
A: It runs 19 hours and 2 minutes, unabridged.
Q: Who narrates Under Your Scars audiobook?
A: Lee Daniels and Joe Arden narrate in duet, each voicing a different male character.
Q: Does Under Your Scars have a happy ending?
A: No. The author states upfront that this book does not have a traditional happy-ever-after, which is unusual for the romance genre.
Q: How can I listen to Under Your Scars audiobook for free?
A: If you're eligible, a free trial may give you a chance to listen to *Under Your Scars* without paying upfront. **Use the free-trial link below to see the current offer and listening options.** You can also check your local library through apps like Libby or OverDrive, although availability may vary.
Q: Is Under Your Scars part of a series?
A: Yes, it's the first book, followed by a novella called Delilah that continues the story years later.
Under Your Scars isn't trying to be everyone's cup of tea, and that's kind of the point. Anderson commits fully to the dark, obsessive tone she's going for, and the choice to skip a happy ending gives the whole thing a weight that a lot of romance simply doesn't have. Lee Daniels and Joe Arden's narration is genuinely the standout here. Two distinct voices carrying two very different men through nineteen hours of tangled obsession, and by most accounts, they nail it.
This one's not for everyone, and honestly, it's not supposed to be. If the content warnings don't scare you off, it's a genuinely intense listen.
